More lawmakers and educators have tried to ban or limit cell phone use in schools over the years. Such a trend has grown over the past years, driven by growing concerns about the negatives of distractions, cyber-bullying, impacts on mental health, and academic performances. By November 2024, some states are working towards implementing such policies Banning the Use of Cell Phones during school hours, while others are considering similar measures.
Current Laws
California: In September 2024, Governor Gavin Newsom of California passed the Phone-Free Schools Act legislation. This law requires each and every public school to create and enforce guidelines dealing with the non-use of a mobile phone by an individual student while they are attending classes from July 1, 2026.
Florida was the first state in the country to make a ban on students’ cell phone usage in school a reality. In May 2023, Governor Ron DeSantis signed House Bill 379 into law; the bill focuses on the importance of traditional education and having fewer distractions.
Indiana, Louisiana, and South Carolina: They have gone down the same path to ban cell phones in schools. South Carolina pushed forward a policy named “Free to Focus SC” that would encourage schools to make campuses phone-free zones with the aim to improve students’ educations.
Ohio: The signing of House Bill 250 by Governor Mike DeWine in May 2024 will see all school districts in Ohio be compelled to adopt official policies regarding the use of cell phones during school hours. This will definitely promise fewer distractions and make students focused.
Proposed Legislation
New York – Governor Kathy Hochul wants to enact a statewide ban on smartphones in schools beginning next year, January 2025. As proposed, the bill will ban kids from accessing the internet at school with their phones, but they will still be able to have devices with them for emergencies.
Kentucky: Legislation regulating student use of cell phones at school will be new bills set for the 2025 General Assembly, says State Senator Steve West. The target areas for this new legislation are three spots of growing concern: Distraction; Discipline, and Mental health.
South Korea: The legislation in South Korea have joined in increasing the ban on phones and other smart devices within schools due to the addiction of social media and problems concerning mental health.
Public Opinion
A Pew Research Center survey conducted in October 2024 found that 68% of U.S. adults support a ban on middle and high school students using cell phones during class, while 36% support a full-day ban. However, there is a sharp divide among age groups, with younger adults being less supportive of these bans.
Conclusion
Meanwhile, arguments regarding a cell phone ban continue to evolve as states develop different ways to grapple with the challenges that technology brings to the classroom. Some say strict restrictions will help boost academic performance and mental health; others believe the answer lies in teaching responsible technology use and keeping open lines of communication between students and parents. As the conversation progresses, it will be crucial to find a balance that supports both educational goals and students’ well-being.